Mighty Moo Ice Cream: Youngtown's Coolest Ice Cream Shop!

If you’re on the hunt for an extraordinary ice cream experience, look no further than Mighty Moo Ice Cream in Youngtown, Arizona. Nestled at 11122 W Alabama Ave G3, this delightful ice cream shop has quickly become a local favorite, boasting a menu that tantalizes the taste buds and evokes pure joy with every scoop.

Mighty Moo is famous for its eye-catching and mouthwatering creations, especially their indulgent sundaes and creamy milkshakes. Dive into their signature Fresh Baked Cookie "Wookie" sundae, a delightful treat that combines warm, gooey cookies with your ice cream of choice for just $7.81. Or opt for the classic Banana Split, featuring a perfect trifecta of flavors—vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate—all drizzled with indulgent toppings that will transport your taste buds to ice cream paradise. With options to customize and build your own sundae, the possibilities are endless at Mighty Moo!

The milkshake menu is equally impressive, priced at $8.07 each, featuring everything from the nostalgic Chocolate and Vanilla Milkshake to the adventurous Fruity Pebbles Milkshake. The richness of the milkshakes, particularly the Peanut Butter Milkshake, makes every sip a heavenly experience. With flavors that are carefully crafted, there's something to suit every palate, making it an ideal spot for family outings or casual date nights.

But what truly sets Mighty Moo Ice Cream apart is the warm and welcoming atmosphere created by owner Tim and his attentive staff. Reviews from customers resonate with their rave about the friendly service and inviting environment. Erik Gibson described the shop as having “the best milkshakes and malts in Arizona,” demonstrating the appeal of both the flavors and the community spirit at Mighty Moo. Customers like Cathy highlight it as a hidden gem, ensuring it remains on the must-visit list for ice cream enthusiasts who find themselves in the Phoenix area.

From the cozy indoor booths to the relaxed outdoor seating, every detail at Mighty Moo is designed to make your visit delightful. It’s a place where families and friends can gather, share laughs, and enjoy deliciously unique ice cream flavors in a cheerful setting.

If you're in Youngtown, don’t miss your chance to indulge at Mighty Moo Ice Cream—it's not just an ice cream shop; it's a sweet escape into a world of flavor and happiness!

Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance

On-site services available
Offers takeaway
No delivery
No same-day delivery

Good for solo dining

Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Erik Gibson

04/12/2025

Mighty Moo Ice Cream has the best milkshakes and malts in Arizona in my opinion. I have been here a few times, and while it is a considerable distance from where I live, it is worth it. I recently visited for the first time since it reopened and changed ownership. The owner, Tim, is a very nice guy who cares about everyone in his shop having a great experience. Even with the change in ownership, the high quality of the ice cream has remained intact. My favorite flavors of ice cream are cake batter, birthday cake, and salted caramel. Their birthday cake ice cream is some of the best I have ever had. It makes a delicious milkshake or malt. I also like their salted caramel truffle flavor. The atmosphere is pleasant and a great place to relax and enjoy your ice cream. It also smells fantastic, especially when you get the aroma of freshly baked waffle cones. Mighty Moo Ice Cream is one of my favorite ice cream places. While I do not get to Youngtown very often, I will definitely stop by whenever I am in the area and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great ice cream place in the Youngtown area.

West Valley Painting

02/12/2025

Best ice cream in town! Delicious flavors and great service. Highly recommend!

Cathy

19/11/2025

Mighty Moo Ice Cream is a hidden gem. I have ice cream everyday, so whenever I visit the Phoenix area, I always make sure to get an ice cream cone at Mighty Moo. They have so many flavors that it’s hard to decide.

Chase Lincoln

14/11/2025

Great hole in the wall set up. The menu was easy to read and the deco was nice and joyful. I got a chocolate shake and my wife got the peanut butter explosion with a brownie. The peanut butter explosion was fantastic, and a warm brownie made it taste even better. Definitely try this place when you can, you will not regret it. I will be going back again and again

Cody Purdy

25/10/2025

This location is a little location in a small strip. They however while being secluded from a main street are non stop busy and still respectful. The lady helping me and my wife was very nice and patient, the menu was easy to read and understand along with a bunch of options. The location it self had roughly 4 indoor seating arrangements as well as some outdoor seating in the back. They had some toys for kids and overall felt like a good family ice cream location. Of the 5 flavors of ice cream we got not one was bad and the addition of a brownie was perfect. Would recommend anyone give this place a try.

Janelle

22/10/2025

What a cute little place with great service and of course delicious ice cream., We’ve been wanting to try Mighty Moo for a while so after even lunch nearby we decided to come check them out. The location is a little small,,but offers a few booths and some tables which was perfect for our group of five. Service was awesome and we all tried different things. I had the cherry amaretto, others had a Dr Pepper float, banana split, cookie topped with Ice cream and another two scoops of other ice cream for our last family member. Everyone really enjoyed their treats. The Icecream was smooth and we all left happy. We will definitely come back when in the area.

J.F. Forests

11/10/2025

An excellent excuse to head over to Youngtown! What a homey little family operation complete with children busy at their computers and staff answering questions and busily scooping delicious sounding unique flavors which I heard they regularly change up. I finally decided on mango sorbet since I was there for a promotion courtesy of local realtors in honor of National Ice Cream Day and they like orange so I decided to "toast" their life-size cutouts. It was nice to see there is also some outdoor seating and some people were taking advantage of that. Oh, about the sorbet: fruitily flavorful and fresh tasting and the texture was velvety smooth! Will certainly return! Update: Went for Cherry Amaretto--see close up pic! Yum-o!

Kristina Harrison

15/09/2025

We stopped in on our way home from date night. They had a nice steady flow of customers on a Friday night. The staff was very nice and patient while my daughter tried to order and struggled with making up her mind. One of the owners was there Tim. Sweet and genuinely kind guy and a very hard worker. Ot was super clean and well lit. There is a few spots to sit amd eat but not a lot, its very cozy. The ice cream was delicious we landed on waffle cones which had ice cream filled from the bottom didn't snag any pictures because it started to melt due to being hot. Definitely worth a try. Struggled to access the menu on their website checked out their Facebook page for their flavors.